| | | | | | | |
 | Jesse Chadwell
Illinois OL | 2013 | | | | |
 | Matt Dellinger Kent State LB | 2012 | |  | Travis Smith Trine University DB | 2012 |
 | Joey Goss Ohio Dominican RB | 2012 | |  | Lucas Sanders Wayne State OL | 2012 |
 | Nick McInally Butler DL | 2011 | |  | Alex Barta Navy P | 2012 |
 | Jordan Clark Adrian College LB | 2010 | |  | Jeff Dean Ferris State DL | 2010 |
 | Tyler Scarlett Michigan Tech QB | 2010 | | | Bryan Haslinger Michigan Tech OL | 2010 |
| Matt Fischer Adrian College OL | 2008 | |  |
Luke Prudhomme Alma College | 2009 |
 
| Ryan Breen Penn State Ohio Dominican P | 2007 | | 
| Bren Bergquist Hillsdale TE | 2007 |
 | Eric Weiland University of British Columbia LB | 2007 | |  | Nick DeVault Northern Michigan University DB | 2006 |
 | Jake Meissnest Saginaw Valley State University OL | 2005 | |  | Andrew Breen Tiffin University P | 2003 |
| | Jon Chesley Adrian College LB | 2001 | | | Cody Senkyr Hillsdale College DB | 2001 |
| | Ryan Kaul Ferris State QB | 2001 | |  | Pat Davis Kalamazoo College DL | 2001 |
 | Bubba Clement Grand Valley State University OL | 2000 | |  | Chad Booker Hope College RB | 2000 |
| | Jay Martello Hope College | 2000 | |  | John Robinson Ohio Wesleyan OL | 2000 |
 | Eric Bauer Albion College OL | 2000 | |  | Eric Kenerson Case Western Reserve University WR | 2000 |
  | Nick Upchurch Central Florida University University of Michigan WR | 1999 | | | Jeff Long Albion College RB | 1998 |
| | Mike Underwood Kalamazoo College DL | 1998 | |  | Mitch Hargett Anderson College DL | 1997 |
| | Jason Graves Grand Valley State University DB | 1995 | | | Pat Mulligan Saginaw Valley State University WR | 1995 |
| | Chad Chandler Saginaw Valley State University LB | 1995 | | | Rusty Mitcham Albion College WR | 1994 |
 | Steve Black Central Michigan DL | 1993 | |  | Jason Hovanec Northwood OL | 1993 |
 | Eric Ryan Adrian College RB | 1993 | | | Jon Wyniemko Central Michigan University WR | 1992 |
| | John King Central Michigan University RB | 1990 | | | Mark Hargett Anderson University | 1990 |
 | Dan Jokisch University of Michigan | 1987 | |  | Jim Hall Brown University | 1988 |
 | Kurt Norman Hillsdale College | 1982 | |  | Steve Wyckoff Saginaw Valley State University | 1980 |
| | | | | | | |
| | Jim Ruelle Hillsdale College | | | | Tom Ruelle Saginaw Valley State University | |
| | | | | | | |
| | George Porritt Hillsdale College | | |  | Tim Fogg Adrian College | |
| | Tom Anderson Adrian College | | | | Tom Ross Saginaw Valley State University | |
| | | | | | | |
 | Tim Doherty Eastern Michigan University | | | | Mike Fogg Alma College | |
| | | | | | | |
| | Mark Warren Eastern Michigan University | | |  | Tom Bullard Colorado College | |
| | | | --- | | | |
